A/HRC/25/54/Add.2
instance, the maximum discount available is 16,000 pounds, and in Northern Ireland it is
24,000 pounds, with both administrations requiring a qualifying period of five years.
41.
In July 2013, the government of Scotland announced its intention to end Right to
Buy for new tenants of social housing from 2017 as part of a new Housing Act that was
introduced in November 2013. When deciding, ministers argued that:
While the [right to buy] has provided new options for households over the last 30
years, the costs of this policy will now fall on future generations. The transfer of
hundreds of thousands of properties out of the social housing sector has decreased
our social housing stock and places increasing pressures on councils and housing
associations. It has also had a profound and detrimental effect on some communities,
with less desirable areas now even more marginalised. At the same time, many of
those who exercised their right to buy have struggled to meet the costs of home
ownership.54
42.
In parallel to these measures, in England grant funding for social housing has been
cut by about two thirds. Housing associations are having to supplement subsidies with
private finance, through guarantee schemes provided by the Government (the Affordable
Homes Programme). To repay the private funding, providers of affordable homes will have
to increase the rents for new social tenants; rents are now allowed to reach 80 per cent of
market rents. Although the Government considers the increase in the rents an incentive for
landlords to invest in housing, this approach has the potential to create other problems,
including reduced affordability and increased reliance on housing benefit. An associated
part of the Affordable Homes Programme has an impact on security of tenure for new
social tenants (or existing tenants when they move) in England: instead of a lifetime
tenancy, they may be offered tenancies for as few as two years.55
43.
Addressing homelessness has also been part of the history of legislation and policy
in the United Kingdom. Of note, the Homelessness etc. (Scotland) Act of 2003 changed the
processes through which local authorities deal with homelessness, and set a target to end
the test of priority need in access to housing by the end of 2012, an approach not found
elsewhere. As the Scottish Human Rights Commission notes, “this target was seen as an
unprecedented commitment and has been interpreted, including by the Scottish Government
itself, as a commitment to an enforceable right to housing by the end of 2012”.56 According
to a project carried out by the Commission, participants were generally positive about the
change brought about by the Act, despite doubts about the targets being met by the end of
the year. Some challenges identified included ensuring the availability and provision of
suitable accommodation for older persons and persons with disabilities.
B.
Welfare reform
44.
The Welfare Reform Act of 2012, adopted by the Westminster Parliament as part of
its fiscal austerity measures, contains measures directly affecting the right to adequate
housing. Most measures apply across the United Kingdom; some do not apply in Northern
Ireland. Due to the strict limit of this report only three aspects are discussed below.
45.
It is crucial to underscore the context of these reforms. The already acute situation
affecting middle- and low-income households is reflected in the lack of sufficient social
housing and an increase in homelessness; increasing unemployment; and rising levels of in54
55
56
Scotland, “The future of Right to Buy in Scotland: consultation report” (2013), para. 3.1.
Information provided by the Building and Social Housing Foundation (October 2013).
Scottish Human Rights Commission, “Getting it right? Human rights in Scotland” (2012), p. 108.
11