http://JUDIS.NIC.IN
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
monitored and the status of compliance of environment conditions was
monitored in 2001 and 2003. Points of non-compliance as and when noticed
have been taken up for necessary corrective action.
Impact on Human Health:
Large quantities of static water provide fertile breeding ground for
diseases carrying vectors. River valley projects have been cited as a cause
to the spread of many epidemics. Considering the fact that reservoir of the
Tehri Project is below 1000m altitude, the chances of vector breeding are
very high. Earlier the Bhumbla committee raised this issue pertaining to
Tehri dam in 1990. But this was not figured in the clearance given to the
Project by the MoEF. HRC Report pointed out this aspect and made the
recommendation to undertake a comprehensive study of the potential health
impacts of the Tehri dam reservoir, reservoir of the downstream dam and the
irrigation canals and mandated to get the plan approved by the Ministry of
Health, Government of India. It also recommended to its quick
implementation. The Government accepted this reference in the HRC Report.
Apart from this acceptance, the petitioners allege that no works have been
carried out.
Right to health is a fundamental right under Article 21. Protection of this
is inextricably linked with the clean environment. Clean and healthy
environment itself is a fundamental right. This position was reiterated by
this Court in M C Metha v. Union of India [2001] 3 SCC 756. Therefore the
impact of the Project on Human Health cannot be given a go by. It has to be
seriously scrutinized.
All the above-discussed aspects aimed at maintaining the ecological balance
and protecting human rights are integral elements of sustainable
development. Rupture to the Himalayan environment, if any, due to the dam
construction could only be compensated by strictly complying with these
conditions attached to the clearance. These aspects are vital for life and
sustainable development of the area. If these aspects are not complied
with, the human life and whole Himalayan environment will be the casualty.
Only its strict compliance could maintain the ecological balance.
Disaster Management :
Disaster Management means all aspects of planning, coordinating and
implementing all measures which are necessary or desirable to prevent,
minimize, overcome or to stop the spread of a disaster upon the people or
any property and includes all stages of rescue and immediate relief. It is
a proven fact that lot of human suffering and misery from large number of
disasters can be mitigated by taking timely actions, planning and
preventive measures. It is possible only through well functioning disaster
management framework. This will enable us to minimize, control and limit
the effects of disaster and will streamline the disaster management
exercises. Our present relief centered re-active approach after the
striking of disaster need to be changed into preparedness oriented proactive attitude. This is the aim of pre-disaster preparations. Disaster
Management Plans has to play an integral role in this exercise. They are
blue prints for the management of disasters. The Disaster Management Plans
should contain the aspects of disaster prevention and of ways for its
management in the untoward occurrence of a disaster. A proper plan will
place the disaster management exercise on a more firm foundation.
It is a welcome gesture that the Clearance to this Project contains a
condition for chalking out disaster management plan. Disaster Management
activities should be integrated with the developmental activities.
Incidentally, this is also the resolve of the Yokohama Strategy of the
United Nations International Decade of Natural Disaster Reduction, to which
India is a party. There is an affirmative obligation on the part of the
State to preserve and protect human life and property. This obligation is
an integral element in fulfilling developmental endeavors. Therefore,
Page 16 of 37