in unequal educational opportunities throughout Kentucky. The local districts have
large variances in taxable property per student. Even a total elimination of all
mismanagement and waste in local school districts would not correct the situation as
it now exists. A substantial difference in the curricula offered in the poorer districts
contrasts with that of the richer districts, particularly in the areas of foreign
language, science, mathematics, music and art.
The achievement test scores in the poorer districts are lower than those in the richer
districts and expert opinion clearly established that there is a correlation between
those scores and the wealth of the district. Student-teacher ratios are higher in the
poorer districts. Moreover, although Kentucky's per capita income is low, it makes an
even lower per capita effort to support the common schools.
Students in property poor districts receive inadequate and inferior educational
opportunities as compared to those offered to those students in the more affluent
districts.
That Kentucky's overall effort and resulting achievement in the area of primary and
secondary education are comparatively low, nationally, is not in dispute. Thirty-five
percent of our adult population are high school drop-outs. Eighty percent of
Kentucky's local school districts are identified as being "poor," in terms of taxable
property. The other twenty percent remain under the national average. Thirty
percent of our local school districts are "functionally bankrupt."
Evidence relative to educational performance was introduced by appellees to make a
comparison of Kentucky with its neighbors--Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, Missouri,
Tennessee, Virginia, and West Virginia. It also ranked Kentucky, nationally in the
same areas.
In the area of per pupil expenditures, Kentucky ranks 6th among the 8 states and
ranks 40th, nationally. With respect to the average annual salary of instructional
staff, Kentucky again ranks 6th among its neighbors and 37th nationally. In the area
of classroom teacher compensation, Kentucky is 7th and 37th. Our classroom
teacher average salary is 84.68% of the national average and our per pupil
expenditure is 78.20% of the national average.
When one considers the use of property taxes as a percent of sources of school
revenue, Kentucky is 7th among our neighboring states and 43rd nationally. The
national average is 30.1% while Kentucky's rate is 18.2%. If any more evidence is
needed to show the inadequacy of our overall effort, consider that only 68.2% of
ninth grade students eventually graduate from high school in Kentucky. That ranks
us 7th among our eight adjacent sister states. Among the 6 of our neighboring states
that use the ACT scholastic achievement test, our high school graduates average
score is 18.1, which ranks us 4th. Kentucky's ratio of pupil-teacher is 19.2, which
ranks us 7th in this region. In spite of the appellants' claim, at both the trial level
and on appeal, that appellees' statistics are not current, all the above figures are
based on a 1986 study, which was published in 1987.
Numerous well-qualified educators and school administrators testified before the trial
court and all described Kentucky's educational effort as being inadequate and well
below the national effort.
With this background of Kentucky's overall effort with regard to education and its
comparison to other states in the area, and nationally, we proceed to examine the
trial court's finding relative to inequity and lack of uniformity in the overabundance
of local school districts. We will discuss the educational opportunities offered and
then address the disparity in financial effort and support.
EDUCATIONAL EFFORT
The numerous witnesses that testified before the trial court are recognized experts in
the field of primary and secondary education. They have advanced college degrees,
they have taught school, they have been school administrators, they have been