MATTHEWS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT
17
European Parliament’s position on a matter can be overruled by a
unanimous Council. Where the EC Treaty requires the Article 189b
procedure to be followed, however, it is not open to the Council to pass
measures against the will of the European Parliament. Finally, where the socalled “assent procedure” is used (as referred to in the first paragraph of
Article 138b of the EC Treaty), in relation to matters such as the accession
of new member States and the conclusion of certain types of international
agreements, the consent of the European Parliament is needed before a
measure can be passed.
In addition to this involvement in the passage of legislation, the
European Parliament also has functions in relation to the appointment and
removal of the European Commission. Thus, it has a power of censure over
the European Commission, which can ultimately lead to the European
Commission having to resign as a body (Article 144); its consent is
necessary for the appointment of the European Commission (Article 158);
its consent is necessary before the budget can be adopted (Article 203); and
it gives a discharge to the European Commission in the implementation of
the budget, and here has supervisory powers over the European Commission
(Article 206).
Further, whilst the European Parliament has no formal right to initiate
legislation, it has the right to request the European Commission to submit
proposals on matters on which it considers that a Community act is required
(Article 138b).
52. As to the context in which the European Parliament operates, the
Court is of the view that the European Parliament represents the principal
form of democratic, political accountability in the Community system. The
Court considers that whatever its limitations, the European Parliament,
which derives democratic legitimation from the direct elections by universal
suffrage, must be seen as that part of the European Community structure
which best reflects concerns as to “effective political democracy”.
53. Even when due allowance is made for the fact that Gibraltar is
excluded from certain areas of Community activity (see paragraph 12
above), there remain significant areas where Community activity has a
direct impact in Gibraltar. Further, as the applicant points out, measures
taken under Article 189b of the EC Treaty and which affect Gibraltar relate
to important matters such as road safety, unfair contract terms and air
pollution by emissions from motor vehicles and to all measures in relation
to the completion of the internal market.
54. The Court thus finds that the European Parliament is sufficiently
involved in the specific legislative processes leading to the passage of
legislation under Articles 189b and 189c of the EC Treaty, and is