16
C E N T E R F O R WO M E N ' S G LO B A L L E A D E R S H I P
quickly, often within a few months, while long-term bonds are repaid over a
much longer period, often many years. Bonds are bought and sold in the bond
market, and once the government issues a bond, it can be traded among investors
in global markets. The price of the bonds varies with conditions in the bond
market. If a government has difficulty finding investors willing to hold its bonds,
the price of the bonds falls until they are sold. From the government’s point
of view, lower bond prices means that borrowing has become more expensive,
since the sale of bonds generates fewer resources. From the investors’ point of
view, lower prices mean a higher rate of return, since the investor has to pay less
money initially in exchange for the future payments the government must make
as stipulated by the bond.
It is important to recognize the difference between budget deficits and the public
debt. Deficits represent how much is borrowed to cover the gap between revenues
and expenditures in a particular budget. The total amount that a government
borrows over time, i.e., the total outstanding amount owed to bondholders, is the
public debt. The public debt represents a claim on future budgets, as interest has
to be paid.
In some cases, formal limitations exist that constrain the ability of governments
to borrow. These restrictions may come from laws or constitutional restrictions
and may only apply to a particular level of government, e.g., state, provincial, or
local governments. Or the limitations may exist because donors place restrictions
on the government’s ability to borrow as a condition associated with their
financial support.
KEY QUESTIONS:
■■
How do we judge whether borrowing is contributing in a sustainable way
to resource mobilization or whether it is simply building up a mountain of
debt that will reduce the resources available for human rights fulfillment
in the future?
■■
What are the distributional impacts of financing government
expenditures by borrowing?
Debt and Assets
To answer the above questions we need to look at the two sides of the balance
sheet—liabilities on one side (i.e., borrowing) and assets on the other. In deciding
whether borrowing can contribute to or hinder the realization of human rights,
it is critical to consider whether the government is using the debt to finance the
creation of assets that will help in the realization of economic and social rights.
Conventional arguments on debt burdens frequently fail to address the asset side.
In other words, if a government borrows, what assets will it be able to create that
would not have been created otherwise? For example, borrowing to build a school
generates social and economic benefits for future generations.