-67188. I end by thanking both legal teams for the excellent arguments prepared and presented. Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers NPJ : 189. I agree with the judgment of Mr Justice Ribeiro PJ. Chief Justice Ma : 190. By a unanimous decision, this appeal is allowed. The Court also makes the declaration referred to in paragraph 144 above and makes the orders as to costs set out in paragraph 145 above. (Geoffrey Ma) Chief Justice (Kemal Bokhary) Non-Permanent Judge (RAV Ribeiro) Permanent Judge (Robert Tang) Permanent Judge (Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers) Non-Permanent Judge Mr Johannes Chan SC and Mr Hectar Pun instructed by Tang, Wong & Chow and assigned by the Legal Aid Department, for the Appellant Lord Pannick QC and Mr Abraham Chan instructed by the Department of Justice, for the Respondent