A/67/302
stakeholder participation in funding processes and programmatic activities in
accordance with the right to health approach to health financing. 32
33. In order to shift the global paradigm of international assistance for health from
a donor-based charity regime towards an obligatory system based on the principle of
solidarity, global pooling mechanisms should be founded upon international or
regional treaties under which States incur legal obligations to contribute to the pool
according to their ability to pay and through which funds are allocated based upon
need. Such a shift is necessary in order to ensure the availability of sustainable
international funding as required by the right to health. In order to promote
ownership and accountability within the regime, each State would contribute to the
fund regardless of its income level and all funding and programmatic processes
must be transparent and include the active and informed participation of civil
society and affected communities. In order to realize the right to health globally,
States should therefore take all necessary steps towards the development of treatybased global pooling mechanisms, comprising compulsory progressive contributions
allocated based upon need and driven by transparent, participatory processes.
B.
Pooling of domestic funds for health
34. The right to health requires States to ensure that good quality health facilities,
goods and services are accessible to all without discrimination. To respect and fulfil
the right to health, States should remove financial barriers that restrict access to
health care. Accordingly, the right to health requires States to ensure that the ability
to pay does not affect an individual’s decision whether to access necessary health
goods and services. Health systems funded by prepayments, such as tax- and
compulsory insurance-based systems, reduce financial barriers through the pooling
of funds collected prior to the point of service delivery. Pooling is a method by
which funds for health are accumulated and managed in order to spread the financial
risk of illness across all members of a pool, over a period of time. 33 Pooling
promotes equitable financing for health by facilitating cross-subsidies from healthy
to unhealthy and from wealthy to poor members of the pool and across the life
cycles of individual members. Pooling also increases efficiency by promoting more
equitable improvements in health across populations 34 and hedging against risks
associated with uncertainties related to future health and financial capacity. 35
35. The primary financial barrier to accessing health care in most States is out-ofpocket payments. Out-of-pocket payments are payments for health goods and
services made by the user at the point of service delivery. In 2007, in 33 mostly lowincome countries, out-of-pocket payments represented more than 50 per cent of total
__________________
32
33
34
35
12-46101
Gian Luca Burci, “Public/Private Partnerships in the Public Health Sector”, International
Organizations Law Review, vol. 6 (2009), pp. 359-382.
WHO, World Health Report 2000, “Health Systems: Improving Performance” (Geneva, 2000),
p. 99.
Peter Smith and Sophie Witter, “Risk Pooling in Health Care Financing: The Implications for Health
System Performance”, Health, Nutrition and Population Discussion Paper (Washington, D.C., World
Bank, 2004), p. 4.
Chris James and William Savedoff, “Risk pooling and redistribution in health care: an empirical
analysis of attitudes toward solidarity”, World Health Report (2010), Background Paper No. 5,
available from: www.who.int/healthsystems/topics/financing/healthreport.
13