Chapter 5 | Page 214
public spending.125 Some argue that aid is positively correlated with quality of
life in democracies while the reverse is true in autocracies, and that this shows
a clear link between aid, quality of life and the political context.126 Others argue
that, despite decades of international aid, some regions such as Sub-Saharan
Africa have not seen much economic growth or social development, which has
prompted many to conclude that aid has failed to achieve its objectives.127
Weaknesses in the design and architecture of international assistance
mechanisms, along with institutional challenges in developing recipient States,
present significant challenges to the ability of States to increase the quantity
and quality of international resources for ESC rights. Policies need to be better
oriented towards maximisation of resource mobilisation efforts and outcomes.
5.3.3.2 Debt management and debt-forgiving
Debt relief is another important form of aid. For the State whose debt is
relieved, this is often the equivalent of a cash transfer (i.e. the amount of funds
that would otherwise be drawn from the government budget for debt payment).
Donors also normally treat debt relief as part of the aid budget.128
Debt burden and debt management have been identified as crucial elements
of the ESC rights debate. In a number of cases, the ESCR Committee
identified the relationship between a State’s foreign debt burden and its ability
to realise ESC rights.129 For example, in its recent Concluding Observation on
Cameroon, the Committee praised the State for its ‘efforts to reach completion
point under the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) initiative, which
enabled it to ease debt and thereby release additional resources to priority
125
Morrissey, above n 39, 142; Peter Lanjouw and Martin Ravallion, 'Benefit Incidence and
the Timing of Program Capture' (1999) 13(2) World Bank Economic Review 257-274.
126
Kosack, above n 113, 11.
127
Morrissey, above n 91.
128
Morrissey, above n 39, 154.
129
CESCR, Concluding observations: Sudan, E/C.12/1/Add.48 (1 September 2000);
CESCR, Concluding observations: Kyrgyzstan, E/C.12/1/Add.49 (1 September 2000).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents