- 1 BvL 12/12 -, III. on the constitutional complaint 1. by Mr. A…, 2. by Ms. A…, 3. by the minor A…, represented by his parents by law, - authorised representatives: KAUF Rechtsanwälte, Karlstrasse 3, 27749 Delmenhorst - against a) the judgment of the Federal Social Court of 28 March 2013 - B 4 AS 12/12 R -, b) the judgment of the Oldenburg Social Court of 10 January 2012 - S 48 AS 1136/11 -, c) the appeal decision of the Delmenhorst Jobcenter of 24 June 2011 617.b-26104BG0017453-W 597/11 -, d) the decision by the Delmenhorst Jobcenter of 12 May 2011 26104BG0017453 - 1 BvR 1691/13 The Federal Constitutional Court - First Senate With the participation of Justices Vice-President Kirchhof, Gaier, Eichberger, Schluckebier, Masing, Paulus, Baer, Britz on 23 July 2014 held that: 4/29

Select target paragraph3