http://JUDIS.NIC.IN
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
disaster management cannot be separated from sustainable development.
The respondents submit that the Ministry of Agriculture has approved the
Disaster Management Plan prepared by the THDC. And added that they are
going to dovetail disaster management plan of the state government at the
District level into the plan prepared by THDC. As regards the disaster
management, the nodal agency is the Ministry of Agriculture and disaster
management plan was approved by the said Ministry in 1992 and a Steering
group has been constituted by the Government in every district under the
chairmanship of district magistrate for flood fighting and related
activities and the Steering group will implement the disaster management
plan in case of any eventuality from the dam. The Government of Uttaranchal
has also constituted a Steering group under the Chairmanship of the
Principal Secretary (Irrigation and Energy), to meet any emergency
situation due to the dam. But effectiveness of all these exercises is in
the proper carrying out of management activities.
Rehabilitation :
The construction of Tehri and Koteshwar dams will result in the formation
of two lakes having a spread of 42 sq. kms and 2.65 sq. kms respectively at
full reservoir levels. The Tehri dam will submerge Tehri town and 22
villages. Another 74 villages will be partially affected. A major potion
will get affected in the first phase with the construction of the Cofferdam
and the remaining by final impoundment. In addition 2 villages fully and 14
villages partially will be affected by the Koteshwar dam. By the
construction of New Tehri Town, project works and colony construction will
affect another 13 villages. In total, Tehri power project will affect 37
villages fully, 88 villages partially and the Tehri town. Rehabilitation of
these much-affected people is the main issue before us.
Rehabilitation is not only about providing just food, clothes or shelter.
It is also about extending support to rebuild livelihood by ensuring
necessary amenities of life. Rehabilitation of the oustees is a logical
corollary of Article 21. The oustees should be in a better position to lead
a decent life and earn livelihood in the rehabilitated locations. Thus
observed tnis Court in Narmada Bachao Andolan’s case (supra). The
overarching projected benefits from the dam should not be counted as an
alibi to deprive the fundamental rights of oustees. They should be
rehabilitated as soon as they are uprooted. And none of them should be
allowed to wait for rehabilitation. Rehabilitation should take place before
six months of submergence. Such a time limit was fixed by this Court in B D
Sharma v. Union of India, [1992] Supp 3 SCC 93 and this was reiterated in
Narmada. This prior rehabilitation will create a sense of confidence among
the oustees and they will be in better position to start their life by
acclimatizing themselves with the new environment.
The rehabilitation package is prepared. It is also made clear that the
rehabilitation conditions in this case are also applicable to the oustees
of Koteshwar dam as well as those living on the rim of the reservoir and to
all those who are likely to be affected by the project. The concerned
authorities will have to take proper steps to rehabilitate all those who
are entitled for rehabilitation before six months of the impoundment.
Without the completion of rehabilitation there shall not be any
impoundment.
According to the affidavit filed by M.L. Sharma, Under Secretary, Ministry
of Power, on behalf of the Union of India, reported on the status of the
follow-up action on the recommendations of the two expert committees
constituted by the Government of India on environment and rehabilitation
aspects of the project and that the recommendations made by the HRC were
considered by the Central Government in consultation with the Government of
U.P. and it was decided to implement those recommendations as per the
decisions indicated against each of the recommendation annexed to the
Office Memorandum dated December 9, 1998. It is also made clear that the
Page 17 of 37