A/HRC/17/34/Add.2
economic opportunities. Despite policy efforts in recent years, the Traveller community
continues to suffer from structural discrimination that causes and perpetuates their
vulnerability to poverty. Particularly striking is their unequal health situation. According to
recent studies, Traveller men can expect to die 15 years earlier than the average Irish
male,63 and Traveller infants are 3.6 times more likely to die than infants in the general
population.64 This level of inequality is simply unacceptable in Ireland, and must be the
immediate focus of State action.
76.
It is not sufficient to simply rely on mainstreaming Travellers in the Irish health
system; addressing structural disadvantage requires affirmative action to eliminate
conditions which have caused or helped to perpetrate inadequate access to health services in
the past. The independent expert urges Ireland to develop, with the meaningful participation
of the Traveller community, a new National Traveller Health Strategy in order to support
the Traveller community’s enjoyment of the right to health on equal footing with the rest of
Irish society.
77.
One factor contributing to the diminished health status of Traveller communities is
the lack of well-equipped halting sites accessible by nomadic Traveller groups. Some
Travellers are forced to halt on unauthorized halting sites with poor conditions and
minimum sanitary facilities,65 which impedes their enjoyment of an adequate standard of
living, and places them at risk of criminal charges.66 The Government should ensure that
local authorities take steps to provide safe, authorized halting sides with adequate
amenities, in consultation with Traveller organizations and groups.
78.
Another crucial area of concern is the Traveller community’s lack of access to, and
equal participation in, the education system. More than two thirds of Travellers aged 15 or
over have no secondary or tertiary education.67 While the independent expert acknowledges
the Government’s well-intentioned efforts to mainstream Traveller children in the
education system, she stresses that mainstreaming is not sufficient to rectify the serious
structural lack of inclusion which leads to the imbalance in access to education. The
independent expert recognizes that in many cases Travellers make a conscious decision,
based on a number of cultural and social factors, not to remain in higher education. The
State should be respectful of this decision while removing barriers to education and
encouraging Traveller children to remain in education where possible. Ireland should also
support efforts by adult Travellers who wish to return to education or training.
79.
Lower education outcomes are one of the main barriers to greater levels of
employment for Travellers. The drastic rise in general unemployment, as a result of the
economic and financial crises, will undoubtedly exacerbate this situation even further,
particularly because Travellers are generally employed in informal or seasonal jobs which
are more vulnerable during times of economic hardship. Ireland should take measures to
ensure that training and employment initiatives are available, and are economically and
socially accessible by members of the Traveller community. The introduction of
employment activation policies with respect to social protection benefits should take into
account the difficulties that Travellers will experience meeting activation obligations,
particularly those Travellers who continue to live a nomadic and extended family lifestyle.
80.
To assist Travellers in overcoming the entrenched discrimination that they suffer,
the independent expert echoes the recommendation of the Committee on the Elimination of
63
64
65
66
67
18
All Ireland Traveller Health Survey “Our Geels” (hereafter Our Geels), 2010, p. 95.
Pavee Point Travellers’ Centre, “Irish Travellers and Roma shadow report,” January 2011.
Our Geels, p. 12.
Housing (Miscellaneous) Provisions Act 2002.
CSO, Equality in Ireland 2007, p. 37.