MOKGORO J CONSTITUTIONAL COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA Case CCT 12/03 LOUIS KHOSA First Applicant ELIASSE MUCAMBO MULHOVO Second Applicant SANIA NDLOVU Third Applicant versus THE MINISTER OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT THE MEMBER OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE FOR HEALTH & WELFARE IN THE NORTHERN PROVINCE _____________________________ First Respondent Second Respondent Third Respondent Case CCT 13/03 SALETA MAHLAULE First Applicant ALTINAH HLUNGWANA Second Applicant versus THE MINISTER OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT THE DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT THE MEMBER OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE FOR HEALTH & WELFARE IN THE NORTHERN PROVINCE Heard on : Decided on : 13 and 30 May 2003 4 March 2004 JUDGMENT 1 First Respondent Second Respondent Third Respondent

Select target paragraph3