A/HRC/26/28
exercise the right to self-determination and the right of all persons to take part in the
conduct of public affairs.67 In this regard, it will also be crucial to build public confidence
that these resources are being well used by, for example, increasing public participation and
oversight of budgeting and expenditure.
53. Income distribution and its management through taxation also have a crucial
relationship with democracy. Growing income disparities can serve to polarize and
fragment societies, which can ultimately lead to alienation and social unrest.68
VI.
Strengthening revenue raising through a human rights-based
approach
54. In order to realize the potential of taxation to fulfil the above-described functions to the
greatest possible extent, there are several actions that States should take. These measures
are examined from the human rights perspective below.
A.
Widening the tax base and improving efficiency
55. In some States, despite significant efforts to increase revenue through taxation, the
amount actually collected is demonstrably inadequate to realize human rights. In Latin
America and the Caribbean, for example, most States have tax ratios that are clearly lower
than they should be when their level of development is considered.69 It is however crucial
that taxes be raised and collected in human rights-compliant ways, where those who can
least afford it are not asked to pay more (see paras. 45 – 50 above).
56. Evidence shows that, even in developing countries, widening tax bases and improving
tax collection efficiency could raise considerable additional revenue.70 For instance, if all
developing countries were able to raise 15 per cent of their national income in tax, a
commonly accepted minimum figure (the OECD average is 37 per cent), they could realize
at least an additional $198 billion per year, more than all foreign development assistance
combined.71
57. Tax collection efficiency can also be increased by improvements in tax administration.
Tax administrations with appropriate financial, personal and technical resources are critical
to increase levels of revenue collection and to avoid abuse. Lack of investment in tax
authorities is therefore a short-term false economy, with negative implications for the
enjoyment of human rights. It is also crucial that tax authorities be perceived as being
independent, fair, transparent and accountable.
67
68
69
70
71
14
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, art. 25. See also A/HRC/23/36.
Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Inequality Matters (see footnote 43), p. 22; IMF, Fiscal
Policy and Income Inequality (see footnote 43), p. 4.
The average tax ratio in Latin America is 18 per cent of GDP. ECLAC, Time for Equality (see
footnote 42), p. 228.
See IMF, Revenue Mobilization in Developing Countries, 8 March 2011, p. 17; UNDP, What will it
take to achieve the Millennium Development Goals? An International Assessment, June 2010, p. 26.
ActionAid, Accounting for Poverty: How international tax rules keep people poor, 2009, p. 5.