A/HRC/14/20/Add.2
provides some additional contextual information about India, Rajasthan and Maharashtra.
The supplementary note explains that India is one of the world’s oldest civilizations,
enjoying a rich, deep, cultural heritage. With a population of over 1 billion people, it is the
world’s largest democracy and second most populous country. In recent years, economic
reforms have turned India into one of the world’s fastest growing economies. Nonetheless,
the country still suffers from high levels of poverty, illiteracy, malnutrition and widening
inequality.
9.
The supplementary note also signals India’s constitutional arrangements,
international human rights commitments, national human rights institutions and recent
substantial progress in the field of health. For example, longevity has doubled from 32
years in 1947 to 66 years in 2004. However, enormous health challenges remain. In the
period 2001–2003 there was an average of 301 maternal deaths for every 100,000 live
births in India.2 While it represents a decrease since the 1997 estimate of 398,3 this figure is
higher than in many other middle-income and some low-income countries.
10.
The supplementary note briefly sets out some of the Government’s health policies
and initiatives, such as the highly commendable National Rural Health Mission (2005–
2012) (NRHM), and includes a few remarks about Rajasthan, with a maternal mortality rate
of 445,4 and Maharashtra, with a maternal mortality rate of 149, i.e. approximately half the
national average.5
11.
A number of especially important contextual issues are not confined to the
supplementary note; they are also set out in some detail in chapters IV and V below. For
example, those chapters discuss the impressive NRHM, the private health sector in India,
the constitutional division of responsibilities for health, and comparative maternal mortality
data, as well as specific health initiatives, such as Janani Suraksha Yojani, Chiranjeevi
Yojana, and a possible role for the National Human Rights Commission.
III. A right-to-health approach to maternal mortality
12.
In collaboration with colleagues, the Special Rapporteur has developed a right-tohealth approach to maternal mortality that derives from international human rights law.
This approach is not specific to India but applies to all countries. It is not possible to
describe fully this approach here. However, it can be found in the supplementary note (and
on the website) referred to in chapter II above.
13.
It would be convenient if the right-to-health approach to maternal mortality could be
reduced to a simple checklist or one-size-fits-all plan of action. But the right to health is
more nuanced, and maternal mortality more complicated, than that. The right-to-health
approach is better understood as a dynamic working model to be applied in diverse contexts
by those committed to the reduction of maternal mortality.
14.
Briefly, the approach entails three steps. First, identifying a number of fundamental
right-to-health values and principles, such as equity, non-discrimination, transparency,
2
3
4
5
GE.10-12866
India, “Maternal mortality in India: 1997–2003: trends, causes and risk factors (Sample Registration
System)” (Registrar General), p. xv. While the Sample Registration System, Maternal Mortality in
India: 2004–2006, was published too late for inclusion in this report, it suggests that the estimated
number of maternal deaths is falling, but remains surprisingly high. Also see “Counting maternal
deaths” in chapter IV below.
India, “Maternal mortality in India”, p. xv.
Ibid., p. 21.
Ibid.
5