CRC/C/GC/13
de facto care of the State. The definition of “caregivers”, referred to in article 19, paragraph
1, as “parent(s), legal guardian(s) or any other person who has the care of the child”, covers
those with clear, recognized legal, professional-ethical and/or cultural responsibility for the
safety, health, development and well-being of the child, primarily: parents, foster parents,
adoptive parents, caregivers in kafalah of Islamic law, guardians, extended family and
community members; education, school and early childhood personnel; child caregivers
employed by parents; recreational and sports coaches – including youth group supervisors;
workplace employers or supervisors; and institutional personnel (governmental or nongovernmental) in the position of caregivers - for example responsible adults in health-care,
juvenile-justice and drop-in and residential-care settings. In the case of unaccompanied
children, the State is the de facto caregiver.
34.
Definition of care settings. Care settings are places where children spend time
under the supervision of their “permanent” primary caregiver (such as a parent or guardian)
or a proxy or “temporary” caregiver (such as a teacher or youth group leader) for periods of
time which are short-term, long-term, repeated or once only. Children will often pass
between caregiving settings with great frequency and flexibility but their safety in transit
between these settings is still the responsibility of the primary caregiver – either directly, or
via coordination and cooperation with a proxy caregiver (for example to and from school or
when fetching water, fuel, food or fodder for animals). Children are also considered to be
“in the care of” a primary or proxy caregiver while they are physically unsupervised within
a care setting, for example while playing out of sight or surfing the Internet unsupervised.
Usual care settings include family homes, schools and other educational institutions, early
childhood care settings, after-school care centres, leisure, sports, cultural and recreational
facilities, religious institutions and places of worship. In medical, rehabilitative and care
facilities, at the workplace and in justice settings children are in the custody of
professionals or State actors, who must observe the best interests of the child and ensure his
or her rights to protection, well-being and development. A third type of setting in which
children’s protection, well-being and development also must be secured, are
neighbourhoods, communities and camps or settlements for refugees and people displaced
by conflict and/or natural disasters. 14
35.
Children without obvious primary or proxy caregivers. Article 19 also applies to
children without a primary or proxy caregiver or another person who is entrusted with the
protection and well-being of the child such as, for instance, children in child-headed
households, children in street situations, children of migrating parents or unaccompanied
children outside their country of origin. 15 The State party is obliged to take responsibility as
the de facto caregiver or the one “who has the care of the child”, even if these children are
not within the context of physical care settings such as foster homes, group homes or NGO
facilities. The State party is under the obligation “to ensure the child such protection and
care as is necessary for his or her well-being” (art. 3, para. 2) and to “ensure alternative
care” to “a child temporarily or permanently deprived of his or her family environment”
(art. 20). There are different ways to guarantee the rights of these children, preferably in
family-like care arrangements, which must be carefully examined with respect to the risk of
these children being exposed to violence.
36.
Perpetrators of violence. Children may be subjected to violence by primary or
proxy caregivers and/or by others against whom their caregiver does provide protection (for
example neighbours, peers and strangers). Furthermore, children are at risk of being
14
15
The United Nations study on violence against children describes settings in which violence against
children occurs; see also the detailed guidance available in the Guidelines for the Alternative Care of
Children.
As defined in the Committee’s general comment No. 6 (2005), para. 7.
13