2017
Measuring Compliance
675
degree of methodological sophistication, allowing for the entry of multiple
explanatory factors and for some sensitivity to statistical noise. The residual
analysis framework that follows builds on the SERF Index methodology in
an attempt to go some way to meeting that demand.
B. Conceptual Framework
The framework that follows borrows from the analytical toolkit of empirical
microeconomics; specifically, those tools that are used to estimate production
function frontiers. According to William Greene, “[t]he frontier production
function . . . is an extension of the familiar regression model based on the
theoretical premise that a production function . . . represents an ideal, the
maximum output attainable given a set of inputs.”72 With the setting of this
ideal comes the theoretical proviso that all observations fall below it. As
such, estimation of the production frontier is generally used as a means to
another analytical end: the analysis of technical efficiency. Analysis of technical efficiency in the microeconomic sense refers to the degree to which
producers are successful in allocating the inputs they have at their disposal
to produce certain outputs in an effort to meet some specified objective. This
objective could be to minimize the number and level of inputs to produce
a given output (input-approach) or to maximize output with a given number
and level of inputs (output-approach). By means of estimating the production
function, a measure of efficiency freely emerges since what it corresponds
to is the distance between the actual observation and the estimate of the
expected ideal.
In the case of measuring the extent to which a duty-bearer is meeting or
falling short of the level of social welfare it has an obligation to fulfill, the
same notion of efficiency can be applied. Each duty-bearer can be treated as a
decision-making unit that “produces” the welfare basket under the behavioral
assumption that it operates to maximize attainment of the basket (output)
given its ability to do so (inputs). Maximum expected attainment at different
levels of resource availability can then be predicted and it is these expected
values that set the obligation frontier. A signal of compliance or violation,
like efficiency, can then be measured as the difference between observed
attainment of the welfare basket and the expected level of delivery, or in
other words, the level states have an unconditional obligation to provide.
72. William H. Greene, The Econometric Approach to Efficiency Analysis, in The Measurement of Productive Efficiency and Productivity Growth 92, 92 (Harold O. Fried, C.A. Knox
Lovell, & Shelton S. Schmidt eds., 2008).