A/66/265
I. Introduction
1.
The present report is submitted by the Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty
and human rights, Magdalena Sepúlveda Carmona, in accordance with Human
Rights Council resolution 17/13. It addresses several laws, regulations and practices,
which have become increasingly common in developed and developing countries,
that punish, segregate, control and undermine the autonomy of persons living in
poverty.
2.
The report benefits from papers presented and opinions expressed at an
international expert meeting hosted by the International Council on Human Rights
Policy in Geneva on 17 and 18 March 2011, which brought together human rights
experts, academics, civil society and representatives of United Nations entities from
all regions, each of whom provided valuable input into the Special Rapporteur’s
report.1
3.
The report uses the term “penalization measures” to refer generally to policies,
laws and administrative regulations that punish, segregate, control and undermine
the autonomy of persons living in poverty. These measures are homogenous neither
in their design nor their effect; they vary significantly in their intent and impact
across and within regions, States, provinces and municipalities. Some result in the
outright criminalization, prosecution and incarceration of persons living in poverty,
while others excessively regulate and control various aspects of their lives. Some
have punitive effects such as the imposition of heavy fines, loss of child custody,
disentitlement from social benefits and infringement on rights to privacy and
autonomy. Some measures explicitly target persons living in poverty while others
are neutral laws, policies and practices which, though directed at all individuals,
have a disproportionate impact on those living in poverty.
4.
The report analyses some of these measures to demonstrate their impact on the
enjoyment of human rights by those living in poverty. The report explains how these
measures are the result of deeply entrenched prejudices and stereotypes that have
permeated public policies. It emphasizes that the negative impacts of these measures
overlap and reinforce one another, exacerbating and perpetuating poverty. The
report applies a human rights framework to demonstrate that, while poverty may not
in itself be a violation of human rights, often States’ actions or omissions that cause,
exacerbate or perpetuate poverty amount to violations of human rights. In this
context, penalization measures represent a serious threat to States’ observance of
their human rights obligations.
II. The realities of poverty: stigmatization, discrimination,
penalization, exclusion
5.
States have long recognized that poverty is a complex human condition
characterized by sustained or chronic deprivation of the resources, capabilities,
choices, security and power necessary for the enjoyment of an adequate standard of
living and other economic, civil, cultural, political and social rights.2 Poverty is not
an autonomous choice, but rather a multifaceted situation from which it may be
__________________
1
2
4
For more information about the meeting, please see www.ichrp.org/en/projects/162.
E/C.12/2001/10, para. 8.
11-44449