Chapter 1 | Page 39
impact on the level of enjoyment of ESC rights and have had significant
negative impacts on the overall standard of living for many.118 Yet, while the
global financial and economic crises have pushed millions of people into
penury― often as a result of the government policy actions to address the
crisis―at the same time the number of wealthy people and their overall net
wealth have increased.119 According to Oxfam, for instance, in 2014 the richest
1 percent owned 48 percent of the world’s wealth while the least well-off 80
percent currently own just 5.5 percent.120 Taking into consideration this
imbalance in resource ownership is critical to understanding resource
challenges to ESC rights.
State efforts to increase resources can also have serious political and social
repercussions if not properly implemented. For example, various interest
groups and issues around the political power balance could easily derail a taxbroadening reform programme, not only holding back future revenue but also
seriously damaging political stability and economic progress. Therefore, as
Philip Alston and Gerard Quinn argue, flexibility for States to implement ESC
rights in a progressive realisation framework should be seen as a necessary
accommodation to the ‘vagaries of economic circumstances’.121 The delicate
balance that needs to be struck in addressing resource mobilisation and
allocation decisions needs to be recognised.
In the case of ESC rights, political and economic contexts are ‘necessarily and
fundamentally determinative’122 and must encompass ‘political, social and
118
For example see, Georg Wenzelburger, 'Fact or fiction? Welfare cuts and fiscal
adjustments' (2014) 34(01) Journal of Public Policy 63-92.
119
Paul O'Connell, 'Let Them Eat Cake: Socio-Economic Rights in an Age of Austerity' in
Aoife Nolan, Rory O'Connell and Colin Harvey (eds), Human Rights and Public Finance:
Budgets and the Promotion of Economic and Social Rights (Hart Publishing, Oxford, 2013)
59, 65.
120
Oxfam, Wealth: Having it all and wanting more <http://policy-practice.oxfam.org.uk/
publications/wealth-having-it-all-and-wanting-more-338125>. Oxfam further identifies that
in 2014, the richest 85 billionaires have the same wealth as the bottom half of the world’s
population.
121
Alston and Quinn, above n 13, 175.
122
Saul, Kinley and Mowbray, above n 33, 170.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents