A/HRC/13/33/Add.4
integral manner. The plan focuses in particular on the production of basic grains; the
promotion of access to the basic food basket; awareness-raising on nutrition and
consumption patterns, including the promotion of breastfeeding; increased coverage and
quality of health, water and sanitation services; and strengthened capacity of SINASAN and
civil society. The latter includes the need for increased coordination between State,
departmental and municipal levels; the creation of a system of information, planning,
monitoring and evaluation of food security programmes ; and the development of a
contingency plan for those areas of the country at high risk of food insecurity.
44.
Despite the above-mentioned plan being in place, and its excellent legal framework,
the institutions set up to implement it appear to have been ineffective in practice. The
limited powers of CONASAN are generally considered a constraint, while SESAN lacks
political weight and has tended to focus on the nutritional aspects of food security rather
than on issues of equity and sustainability. The creation of social programmes to promote
food security outside the institutional framework has also raised issues of coordination and
consistency. This relates specifically to a range of programmes aimed at combating hunger
and poverty coordinated by the so-called Council on Social Cohesion (see section VII
below).40 In this regard, the Special Rapporteur notes the risk of a weakening of SINASAN
and CONASAN and possible duplication of efforts. This risk of duplication also exists with
the Comisión Nacional Gabinete Especifico Socio Ambiental and the Comisión Nacional
del Programa de Emergencia para la Generación de Empleo, Seguridad Alimentaria y
Nutricional, Sostenibilidad de los Recursos Naturales y Gobernabilidad. It should be
recalled that one of the main advantages of a national strategy is to improve coordination
across different branches of government and programmes. Its purpose would be defeated by
the coexistence of multiple, uncoordinated strategies involving different sets of actors.
B.
Food insecurity and vulnerability diagnosis
45.
In his report on the 2005 visit, the Rapporteur’s predecessor noted the creation of
SINASAN as a “hunger early warning system”, which “monitors and evaluates the impact
of food security programmes and provides an early warning to identify potential crisis
situations”.41
46.
Following the creation of SINASAN and CONASAN under the 2005 Law, the
System of Information and Communication on Food and Nutrition Security (SICSAN) was
set up and placed under the responsibility of SESAN. The system was however dismantled
in 2007, only to be relaunched by the current administration. If it is to manage an effective
early warning system, SESAN should be strengthened. It currently has less than 100
employees, at national and regional levels, and an annual budget of less than US$ 2 million.
However, the deaths registered as a result of acute malnutrition in the dry corridor this year
placed the consequences of the failure to consolidate such a system in stark focus. While
taking note of two recent protocols on mandatory notification of cases of malnutrition, the
Special Rapporteur calls upon the Government to urgently improve its early warning
system.
40
41
This Council is headed by the First Lady and composed of representatives of the the Ministry of
Education (MINEDUC), the Ministry of Public Health and Social Assistance (MSPAS), SESAN, the
Secretariat of Social Works of the Spouse of the President (SOSEP), the Ministry of Public Finance
and the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Food (MAGA).
E/CN.4/2006/44/Add.1, para. 35.
13